The Cultural Changes of Whalesong
Love Music More · hosted by Luke F. Walton · Solo episode
The podcast feed is titled Love Music More with Scoobert Doobert. Scoobert Doobert is Luke F. Walton's primary music project.
Listen
Topics discussed
Host note
This is the end of the run. What Babies Listen To, Fishbowls of Influence, Monkey Studies. The question is still what we show up with and what a culture trains. This week is birds. In 2009, researchers showed that Snowball the cockatoo did more than bob along. They sped the song up and slowed it down, and Snowball sped up and slowed down with it. Ten years later, Snowball was coming up with dance moves to different music. I like the puncture. Zebra finches learn their songs, so the song is being copied, passed on. A 2021 study had male zebra finches keep track of regular sequences through substantial tempo changes. That is the part I care about. Happy Birthday survives every key, and the keys between the keys, and it survives being sung fast or slow.
The song is the relationship. That is what Giosuè Greco and I had just been saying: a great song is a great song on any instrument, and it does not even need to be the greatest instrument. Snowball and the finches are tracking that relationship across a change in timing, the same statistical expectation I talked about with newborns. Where will the rhythm fall. Where will the melody go. Some parrots can lock their bodies to a beat. Then I went back to monkeys. A 2025 paper I had just read is called Monkeys Have Rhythm. Two adult macaques were trained to tap a click on a microphone, then tested on real music, and they synced those taps to a subjective beat. The earlier macaque result was brain activation at an irregularity. This one is participation, a small one, and it took a lot of training. A dog tapping a foot would still stop me. The machinery is there, the way it is there for Snowball. I can do more than tap for treats. It leaves me feeling tangled up with the music, and it leaves the alien question as a thought experiment: would they have music. The signs, across more than mammals, point at maybe.
Then the whales, which is the title. One population's song gets replaced by another population's song, and researchers watch those songs move across the South Pacific for years. There is a Billboard Hot 100 of whale song. A 2022 study followed six song types from Eastern Australia to New Caledonia. The New Caledonian whales sang them with high fidelity. They were singing along to the original, a cultural migration, and the songs have rhythmic organization inside them. They are a sequence, with time in them.
The part I want to leave on is the pattern matching. Researchers took eight years of humpback recordings and ran something like the way a human infant finds words: syllables that keep arriving together get treated as a chunk. They found statistically coherent chunks in the songs. I am calling that word-like. They kind of have lyrics, and I will leave the language claim there. I have a song about a whale and I cannot remember the record. It is I Am a Lobster, I Am a Barnacle, on Little Hug. The whales remember theirs.
Selected moments
- Birds, after the babies and the monkeys 0:57 I pick up the series and turn it toward birds, starting with Snowball the cockatoo.
- Snowball matches the tempo 1:26 I stay on the 2009 result, where the song speeds up and slows down and Snowball does too.
- Happy Birthday, and the finches 2:37 I use a 2021 zebra finch study, and Happy Birthday in every key and tempo, to argue that the pattern survives the change.
- A great song on a lesser instrument 3:14 I bring in the conversation with Giosuè Greco: a great song holds on any instrument, even one that is not the greatest.
- Monkeys Have Rhythm 4:58 I go back to macaques, via a 2025 paper where two adults tap a beat in real music after training on a click.
- A tap is a small kind of participation 6:04 I keep the limit in view: a trained tap is synchronization, and it is a long way from hearing a song and dancing.
- A chart of whale song 7:39 I describe song revolutions moving across the South Pacific, including a 2022 path from Eastern Australia to New Caledonia.
- Chunks, the way infants find words 8:44 I explain the pattern-matching on eight years of humpback recordings, using the infant method of grouping likely syllables.
- The whales remember 9:42 I admit I cannot remember which record my own whale song is on, and I envy the whales for keeping theirs.
Selected excerpts
They were able to speed up and slow down the song and Snowball sped up and slowed down its movement. Snowball was actually dancing.
The song Happy Birthday can be sung in every key and every key in between every key, but it's still Happy Birthday.
Being able to understand the relationship between pitches at different timing, that means that they are actually creating a relationship.
It's called Monkeys Have Rhythm. Hell of a title.
They were able to tap along to music, the monkeys.
There is a Billboard Hot 100 of whale song.
They might not have language, but they kind of have lyrics.
Unlike the whales, they remember all their songs. I don't remember all of my songs.
FAQ
Can birds keep a musical pattern when the tempo changes?
On the studies I talk through here, yes. Snowball the cockatoo sped up and slowed down with the track in the 2009 work, and ten years later had new moves for different music. A 2021 study had male zebra finches distinguish regular sequences through substantial tempo changes. Happy Birthday is my human version of the same fact. Any key, any speed, it is still the song.
Do monkeys have rhythm?
The 2025 paper I had just read is titled Monkeys Have Rhythm. Two adult macaques were trained to tap a click, then they tapped along to a subjective beat in real music. That is participation, and it took a lot of training. A trained tap is a long way from hearing a song and dancing.
Do humpback songs move between populations?
That is the cultural change in the title. One population's song gets replaced by another's, and researchers watch the songs travel the South Pacific. A 2022 study followed six song types from Eastern Australia to New Caledonia, sung there with high fidelity, along to the original.
Do whale songs have words?
I don't have a language claim, and I say so on the episode. Researchers took eight years of humpback recordings and used a method like the way infants find words, chunking sounds that keep arriving together. They found statistically coherent chunks. I call that lyrics-like.
Transcript
0:57 What's good everybody?So I've been obsessed about babiesand Bolivian tribes and monkeysand trying to figure out what's up with music really.What do we know in terms of what actually is out thereand what is default, what is learned,what is our fishbowl, what is the water in which we swimand I wanna talk about birds now because I'm not done yet.And I was just reading about snowball, the cockatoo.
1:26 So 2009 researchers showed that snowball danced to musicas any internet aficionado would say of courseI have watched many a bird dance.But the crazy thing about snowballis that they were able to speed upand slow down the songand snowball sped up and slowed down its movement.Snowball was actually dancing.And then 10 years later,they proved that snowball was coming upwith dance moves to different music.That's crazy.
2:02 So I'm not saying that snowballis equivalent to human dance,but it does make you kind of go,I don't know, I like it when certain thingsthat are so human you get a little punctureand like whale song or bird song or a bird dancing.There's also a really cool thing with zebra finches.They learn their songs.And so it's not necessarily just a genetically fixed thing,a inherited thing.They are replicating it.
2:37 And in 2021, there was a study where male zebra finches,they learned to distinguish regular sequenceseven with substantial tempo changes.The tempo changes is a much bigger dealthan I think it seems at first glancebecause one of the things I love is happy birthday.The song happy birthday can be sung in every keyand every key in between every key,but it's still happy birthday.It can be sung really fast.
3:14 It can be sung really slow.It's still happy birthday.Why?How do we do that?I just had a wonderful conversation with film composerand we were talking about a great song is a great song.So put it on any instrument.He went even further and he was saying,it doesn't even need to be the greatest instrument.This is just way Greco, by the way.Incredible guy, incredible composer.Definitely check out that episode.
3:45 But what we were saying is the song itselfis the relationship.And so when you have a bird like snowballor these zebra finches,being able to understand the relationship between pitchesat different timing,that means that they are actually creating a relationshipin the same way that when I was talking about the newborns,creating the relationship and the expectation
4:18 within the statistical model of where will a rhythm fall?Where will a melody go?And we see this with mimicry.But I think this is bigger than just mimicry.This is saying I get it.I'm interacting with it across a broader thing.So some parrots are able to synchronize their bodiesto musical beats.Songbirds are able to learn this timing prediction.Human newborns, we've already talked about.
4:58 They have this statistical prediction.Adult humans, obviously have all of this.But there's this cultural componentjust like we saw with the chimane.So what is this?Where do we go?We go back to monkeys.So this one is crazy.2025 in science, I just read it.It's called monkeys have rhythm.Hell of a title.Two adult macaques were trained on explicit microphone tapping.So, you know, got the click.
5:32 And then they were tested on real music after that.They were able to synchronize their taps,these monkey taps, to a subjective beatin actual music.They were able to tap along to music, the monkeys.That's crazy.So it's not just the other study that I was talking aboutwhere they were able to have brain activationbased on irregularities.This was participation in music.Minor participation.Granted, this is a tap.
6:04 But still, it'd be pretty crazy to look over to your dogand see your dog tap in their foot to music.This is something beyond just like rhythmic groupingor sensitivity.This is synchronization.So no, this doesn't mean that a monkeycan just hear a song and dance, right?Like that was a lot of training.But that shows that at the very least,there's machinery in their brains to be able to do this
6:33 in the same way that there's the machinery in a snowball,the cockatoo to be able to rip it up on the dance floor.So I say this not to diminish humans, like obviously,we can do more than tapafter being fed lots and lots of treats.However, I think it actually should make us feelmore integrated with music itselfand also maybe have some hope that musicis truly a universal language.Here I am with those aliens again,
7:09 but regardless of aliens are real or not,they are a fun thought experiment.How would they go about learning music?Would they have music?And I think at least all of the signsacross multiple species, not just mammals,science point to maybe.And if you'll humor me with one more mammal,let's talk about whales.So one of the things that I think is really wildis just the cultural changes of whale song.
7:39 So there will be these song revolutionswhere one population song gets replacedby another song from another population.And the researchers will watch songsmoving across the South Pacific over years.The songs are catching up.There is a Billboard Hot 100 of whale song.A 2022 study followed six song typesthat moved from Eastern Australiaall the way to New Caledonia.And the New Caledonian whales,
8:11 they were able to produce these songs with high fidelity.They were not simplifying them.This was like a cultural migration.They were singing along to basically the original.And the whale songs have rhythmic organization.It's not just one giant drone or moan.There is temporal organization inside of these songs.And what I think is crazyis as we get better at machine learning.So say what you want about AI.
8:44 I think machine learning like pattern matchingcan be really, really wild for things like thisbecause researchers, they took eight yearsof humpback song recordingsand they applied a method similar to human infantswhere they're trying to use the human infant'sdiscovery process for wordswhere the babies, they're able to likeuse the probabilities where if a certain syllable
9:09 comes together, they start to treat them as a chunkand then they start to learn them as a word.You can apply the same thing to a humpback songand they're able to find statistically coherent chunks.Like, not saying they have language,but there are word-like meanings inside of their songs.They might not have language, but they kind of have lyricsand I'll leave you with that.Let's sing along to some whale songs.
9:42 Maybe that'll be my next record.Don't tempt me with a good time.If you enjoyed this podcast, I would like for youto listen to my whale songs.I do have a song about a whale.It's on my, I think it's on Big Hugand it's weird or is it Little Hug?You go tell me.I've made too much music.I've forgotten it all.Unlike the whales, they remember all their songs.I don't remember all of my songs.
10:06 Go to scoobertdoobert.pizza to find outand you can also check out my weird pizza shopthat I made over there.I'm not gonna tell you any more about that.And like five stars, share, share with your friendsand I will see you next week.Thank you for listening.
The transcript above is a reviewed transcript of this episode (JSON). The recording is the Spotify episode.